3 Comments

Same. Rarely, rarely, rarely do I come in under required word counts -- and that holds for an 800 word op-ed piece, a 1200 word book review, a 7500 word journal article, or an 80,000 (or 100,000) word book manuscript. I swear, no matter the format, I'm inclined to go long. I've reached the point in my books where I create a "cutting room floor" document from things that editors cut/requested I cut. From my last book I probably will emerge with an entirely new book, two conference papers that will become articles, and at least 1-2 other shorter things. Hell, I intended this comment to be half as long as it turned out.

Expand full comment

I struggled to get the PRL that got me my faculty job down to four pages. I cut and cut and cut. I believed that it was within the limit and submitted it. When the paper was published it went onto a fifth page. It was only a couple of lines over and there was an almost completely black page left. All that work to shorten it wasn't needed.

Expand full comment

My writing tends to the opposite extreme, 400-800 word pieces.

I do write slightly longer and freer by hand, but typing exaggerate the brevity.

Expand full comment