Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Cisko's avatar

Finished ep3 tonight of Wot and I'm enjoying it so far. Fortunately my wife is too. I'm with you on Perrin's wife, but I'm not feeling the same angst over his character. They're playing the trauma pretty thick for him, but otherwise I think he's just really quiet, which fits for me. Wish Mat could've started a bit more cheerful, so we could see where his character develops. But other than that I'm very happy with the characterization.

I've been feeling the geography issues in these kinds of things for a while - thanks for calling them out. The scenery is beautiful but doesn't make much sense; I think shows are taking the wrong lessons from LotR. I'd prefer if it aligned with my mental map of Emonds Field > Baerlon > Whitesbridge > Tar Valon, but even if you diverge from the book maps, it's just random places with no sense of connection.

So far though, well done. Every episode has a few beautiful moments, and the plot divergences fit and make sense so far. Fingers crossed but I have good vibes to this point.

Expand full comment

No posts