There was a flare up this past week of “Two Cultures” argument over on ex-Twitter and, as is almost always the case, this was very, very stupid. The whole thing started off with the common claim that people in STEM are more likely to have “deep interests in literature a philosophy and the arts” than vice versa, but quickly devolved into people arguing about whether those on the other side were engaging with the very latest in scholarship in either of those groups of subjects. This is, of course, a completely ridiculous standard: professional academics within these fields barely engage with the latest scholarship in subfields outside their own personal areas of research. Asking whether some amateur is reading the very latest peer reviewed work in one field or another is just farcical. At the end of the day it’s probably best summed up by this tweet:

“No-one reads, and everyone is bad at math;” put that on T-shirt and you’ll make bank.
The whole problem with the (very predictable) way this developed is that the the premise is ill-founded to start with. The whole “Two Cultures” question has never really been about deep interest in particular subjects, it’s always (fairly explicitly) been about shallow interest in things, and especially expectations of what shallow interests one should have. That’s where the difference is that I think gets under people’s skin and makes this such an evergreen topic (while also being a very futile one).
In addition to dumb ex-Twitter #content, as the summer months have been winding down I’ve also been seeing a lot of other people’s travel and vacation photos on social media. I think there’s an element there that provides a more concrete illustration of the real issue, one that’s perhaps a useful heuristic for thinking about this whole business: What museums do you go to when you’re on vacation?
That is, I have a lot of friends who are scientists, many of whom travel during the summer months, and their vacation photos are full of visits to historical sites, art museums, and cultural institutions. I also have a fair number of friends who are not in any way scientifically inclined, and their photos are pretty much full of the same things: many of the very same historical sites, art museums, and cultural institutions.
What’s noticeable by its absence is photographic documentation of people who are not scientifically inclined visiting scientific places. You don’t regularly see adults traveling without children going to a natural history museum, let alone a science museum. Even zoos and aquariums are not common destinations for adult tourists.
So, while the strong claim of “deep interest” is not particularly well founded, I think there is some truth to the idea of that people on the STEM side of the Two Cultures divide tend to have at least a shallow interest in art and culture, one that is not reciprocated. STEM folks will go to those sorts of institutions and seek out those kinds of experiences, but people on the not-STEM side do not show the same interest in anything approaching scientific.
Now, to be fair, my scientist friends who are traveling without children also tend not to visit natural history museums and and science museums as frequently as they visit art museums. This is in large part because these spaces tend to be very strongly kid coded: the displays are mostly pitched at children, and the buildings and spaces are frequently full of of young children, which and this can be sort of enervating if you’re an adult traveling without kids of your own. It’s not that the subject matter doesn’t appeal—I’ve been to science museums with professional physicists without accompanying children, and I can assure you that that they are just as fascinated by the displays as the little kids are. But this isn’t a thing that people tend to do, because it’s a space that is seen primarily as a space for children.
But that’s also an illustration of exactly the problem that the whole Two Cultures idea is getting at, and that gets people upset about these things. Interest in science is very much seen as a Childish Thing that one puts aside as one becomes an Adult. There’s an expectation that when one is an educated and independent member of society, one will continue to be interested in seeing great paintings and amazing sculptures (and works of contemporary art of whatever value), but there is no parallel expectation that one will continue to be interested in dinosaurs, or animals, or space travel. Science museums are for kids, while art museums are for everyone.
Again, I don’t think this reflects a real deep engagement with the subject matter on either side. I don’t think that going to the Met when I’m in Manhattan with an afternoon to kill counts as, you know, engaging with art in a in a really profound way. And I wouldn’t say that somebody going to the Natural History Museum on the same basis would count as deep engagement with science. But I think it’s a basically undeniable fact that one of these things is much more likely to happen than the other. You simply don’t see adult tourists without children in most of the spaces that are dedicated to more science-oriented content. Even aquariums and zoos are almost exclusively families with children1, not adults going to appreciate science and nature for their own sake. On the flip side, if you go to an art museum you will nearly always see families with smaller kids in among the adults— art and culture are presumed to have a universality that science is not. (A belief that is quite at odds with the actual fact of science as a universal human activity. Which I’ve written an entire book about…)
The reasonable and appropriate question to raise at this point is: Does this actually matter? That is, is there any real significance to the difference in cultural cachet of these sorts of shallow institutions, especially when compared to, say, the amount of funding available for various kinds of enterprises in these different areas? I don’t have a quantitative answer for that (or a clear idea how one might find one), but at the same time, I find it hard to imagine that it’s completely without significance. The common perception of science as something for small kids and weird adults more or less has to work against its perceived prestige, to the detriment of everyone.
If nothing else, it gives people working in STEM some very real justification for feeling mildly aggrieved…
This is another of the ongoing experiment of dictating blog posts into Google Docs (in this case dictating it while sitting on our deck). If this is of interest, either in form or content, here’s a button:
And should you feel so moved, the comments will be open:
When I was in Long Beach last summer by myself, I killed a few hours at the Aquarium of the Pacific, and I am fairly certain I was the only childless adult in there. I got some weird looks.



Another way to look at this is that we have a lot less casual exposure to science than we do to humanities. Art and music are on display everywhere, and "entertainment" is almost by definition the arts. On the other side, we miss the everyday science of the world around us unless someone stops to point it out.
In grad school a humanities friend of mine once pointed out that all the STEM grad students she knew has some art-adjacent hobby - a few were in the city orchestra, others were into photography or painting - but none of her humanities friends had anything science-y on the side. Now some of that might be a lack of science-related hobbies - nowadays I can think of birding, flying drones/model airplanes... and then I start to run dry. Keeping fish? Breeding roses? Local environmentalism? Battling robots? But that observation always stuck with me, and it seems common enough to start Twitter wars. now, so there may be some truth to it.
Of course, the other social media outrage that crossed my field of view was Tucker Carlson and an interviewee agreeing that they know no one who uses algebra and who are these idiots putting letters in math, anyway? So the problem may be less the Two Cultures and a performative third on that trashes them both.